Tue, May 29, 2007 15:00 EDT

Why Your BlackBerry Causes Speakers to Buzz

Topic: Infrastructure

Blog: Mobile WorkHorse

Current Rating: 5 Comments: 54

A few weeks back, I reviewed four smartphones in conjunction with a handful of IT executives. In that review, I briefly touched upon the annoying buzz the Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM) phones caused when sending or receiving a communication in close proximity to speakers—radio, computer, car, auditorium, whatever.(Specifically, that the BlackBerry Pearl seemed to yield more buzzing than any of the other phones we reviewed.)

 

Recently, I was reminded of this frustrating phenomenon at MIT’s Sloan CIO Symposium when the overhead Bose speakers in the main auditorium began buzzing like disgruntled honey bees. I looked directly to my right to find the guy next to me tapping away maniacally on his BlackBerry. He didn’t even notice the buzzing, but there were a number of smiling faces across the room that quite obviously did. All day, I couldn’t help but notice how many handhelds were in use around me. BlackBerrys, Treos, iPaqs, T-Mobile Dash phones, various Motorola and LG handsets and plenty of others I didn’t recognize at first glance. And nobody could stop playing with themselves for more than a minute or two, be it during a session or while networking.

 

Let me start by saying that regardless of the title of this blog post, the buzzing speaker issue is by no means caused only by BlackBerrys. I chose the title based on my own experience with the handhelds and the fact that the Cingular Pearl was the device that caused the most frequent and most pronounced buzz of the four phones I recently reviewed. (That, and because I know many of you are so addicted to your BlackBerrys that you'll read anything with "the B word" in the title.)

 

To get to the root of the issue, I spoke with Duncan Bradley, Research In Motion's (RIM) director of global market intelligence. RIM is the BlackBerry manufacturer. Bradley explained to me that cell phones cause this buzzing interference when near some speakers or other devices that can resonate radio frequencies (RF) because such devices often feature poor quality shielding mechanisms to block radio waves from being received. The devices act as passive antennas, picking up cell phone radio signals, but they don't have any way to modulate or translate them into anything intelligible, according to Bradley. Speakers or other electronics with higher quality shielding mechanisms yield less buzzing when near phones, he said.

 

Bradley also informed me that it’s

You do not have flash or javascript support.
Average (17 votes)
5
 
 
Tue, May 29, 2007 19:20 EDT
Posted by: remi
Rating: 90

This is a very informative article, thank you. I am using a Dash from T-Mobile, mostly in the Bay Area, where I work and live.

While I understand the annoyance of the buzz, I am curious to know when the Bay Area will finally be properly covered by the major operators. I cannot believe the number of spots where there is no signal. I would give the buzz a priority 1,000 compared to this one!

 
Wed, May 30, 2007 13:05 EDT
Anonymous user
Posted by: Vince
Rating: 90

It's not relly the speaker itself. Here's the mechanism:

The speaker coil and the cable from the amplifier act as an antenna. The radio frequency signal (RF) is led thereby to the last stages of the amplifier, and often from there via the gound of the system to eariler stages.

The semiconductors in the amp convert some of that radio wave to audio noise, and that noise gets amplified back and presented to the speaker.

I am clarifying this to calm some worries. If it was a matter of the radio wave exciting the speaker directly, there would simply not be enough energy to be audible. Without knowing this fact, people might assume that there is a whole lot of dangerous RF energy from the wireless device, when in fact it is a very tiny amount.

A technician cam remove this interference completely, not best by huge amounts of shielding, but by adding a few bypassing componemts at the output of the amp, TV, or other audio device.

 
Wed, May 30, 2007 13:12 EDT
Anonymous user
Posted by: Vince
Rating: 90

OH, BTW, in the case of the auditorium sound system or a component audio system, it is just as likely to happen due to that energy coming into the inputs, like via the microhone cable or the interconnecting cables. Same bypassing rules apply.

For technicians wishing to solve this problem for their equipment, I recommend the ARRL publication about Radio Frequency Interference. (title?)

 
Wed, May 30, 2007 18:27 EDT
Anonymous user
Posted by: Vince
Rating: 90

As far as the seriousness of the problem, it is low to medium importance at this time, but will get rapidly worse as wireless technology prolifertes.

I lay this directly in the lap of the FCC (here in America, anuway.) Equipment can be designed to minimize susceptibility to interference, but since it is not something that can ber determined to be a problem in the electronics showroom, some sort of susceptibility rating should be mandated to be reported "on the box", if not a mandate requiring better resistance to interference.

The added component costs are trivial. Remember, it's not the fault of the transmitters, but the existing receivers.

Out of curiosity, I did a few searches for aftermarket interference-limiting devices and surprisingly I found very little. There should be RF-filtering audio adaptors, speaker filters with quick connectors, and the like. There are a few, but not in the mainstrean electonic supply, other than the snap-on ferrite chokes at Radio Shack, which are not terribly effective for this type on interference.

I really expect this to change, though, as the problem gets worse. Also, fiber optic interconnects for audio equipment are becoming more common, which are completely immune to RFI.

Footnote: Corporations play games with regulation, too. A few decades back. a major computer manufacturer in the UK introduced their education-oriented machine into the US. Their US competitors managed to get the govenment to specify strict noise output regulations on the imported product, but not the domestic competitor. The shielding required easily added $50 to the foreign product, which amounted to a hidden import duty. (This was before PCs were as universal)

Mostly, it seems to me, the FCC responds to corporation's needs rather than those of the users.

 
Sun, Jan 4, 2009 11:51 EST
Anonymous user
Posted by: Kirk
Rating: 90

Vince-
I recently read that the cylindrical magnetic things that come on many USB cables can stop this buzzing if attached to the car speaker cable near the speaker. I've been collecting them to try on my wife's Acura, which has a buzzing problem with her iPhone 3G. Her Motorola Razr was much worse. Are these the Ferrite Chokes that you speak of? If so, I won't bother trying them.
On the other hand, my Mercedes, which uses a fiber optic loop between all the electronic components has no buzzing problem with my iPhone 3G, which confirms your point.

Thanks,

Kirk

Post new comment

* Subject:
* Username:
* E-mail:
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Homepage:
* Body:
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <blockquote> <strike> <p> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
More information about formatting options

* Denotes required field.

About this Blog

Al Sacco writes about (and drools over) anything and everything mobile or wireless as it applies to the global workforce--with a focus on BlackBerry smartphones.

Got tips? Send 'em Al's way.

Follow this blog on Twitter: @MobileWorkHorse.

Start a Conversation
Click to post

Got something to say? We want to hear it! Click the Post button to get started. GO»

EXPERT ADVICE
See our roster of experts.

Advice & Opinion from more than 117 of IT's most insightful thinkers.

  PARTNERS       WEBCASTS    
 

Register for more Windows Enterprise Webcasts today

Each month, Microsoft features a different customer or analyst discussing how Windows 7 and the Windows Optimized Desktop can impact your organization in positive ways, including helping IT to streamline management and manage risk while helping your employees increase productivity.

Sponsored by Microsoft  Listen to on-demand Recordings »

 

A Framework for Better Application Delivery

The complexity of application delivery is driven in part by the evolving applications environment. Instead of approaching application delivery from a siloed fashion, this handbook looks at end-to-end guidance and discusses the impact of ignoring the WAN, Web apps that are chatty, data center consolidation, SaaS, Web 2.0 and virtualization.

Sponsored by Riverbed  Read this White Paper »

 

Microsoft® Exchange 2010 includes archiving - but is it enough?

Microsoft® Exchange 2010 includes basic email archiving. But many organizations will find that it does not meet their requirements. This paper describes why organizations need to archive, what capabilities Exchange 2010 includes and why 3rd party archiving solutions will be necessary for most organizations.

Sponsored by Google, Inc.   Read this White Paper »

CIO's Virtualization Newsletter

Receive virtualization news on the latest technologies and developments, expert opinions on managing your data center and practical case studies for your next implementation.

CIO's Virtualization Newsletter

Receive virtualization news on the latest technologies and developments, expert opinions on managing your data center and practical case studies for your next implementation.

Enterprise Capture: Your Onramp to Business Process Automation

Today more than ever companies are seeking to reduce costs and...  View Now »

 

The True Cost of Legacy Systems

How well are you maximizing existing software assets? This webcast reveals the results of a commissioned study on top migration and modernization priorities for IT leaders.   View Now »

 

How To Maximize Your Virtualization Strategy and Deployment

Join award-winning technology journalist Stan Gibson in this webcast as he discusses how to enhance your virtualization strategy with the ROI, planning, implementation and platform advice. Exploit the business benefits of virtualization and successfully expand your current deployment.   View Now »

CIO's Virtualization Newsletter

Receive virtualization news on the latest technologies and developments, expert opinions on managing your data center and practical case studies for your next implementation.

 
Newsletter Sign-Up »

Receive the latest news test, reviews and trends on your favorite technology topics

Sponsored Links

Getting ready to upgrade to Windows 7? Attend Microsoft's Virtual Event on 4/22 for all the tools you'll need. Register Now!

Ready to create safe, business class social networking tools? View Now

Let Progress Software help your business make progress.

HP pays back. Trade in your old printer and get up to $1000

Read report on how to improve decision making with business analytics.

Dynamic Virtual Client: Whats in store for client technology going forward?

The ISP that focuses exclusively on information security? SecureWorks.

Supercharge Your End Users with Desktop Virtualization

Manage limitless content todayread EMCs 15-minute guide to ECM.

HP Exstream. Get a Free Document Assessment for Financial Services.

Take the Netezza TwinFin TestDrive!

Webinar: Jump-start your in-house e-discovery with Ringtail QuickCull from FTI Technology

See why ShoreTel is named best overall VoIP provider by Nemertes Research

Trend Micro ranked #1 against real-world malware. Read more.

Turn your desk phone and mobile phone into one with Sprint Mobile Integration.

Maximizing efficiencies with unified communications.

Stay informed with custom newsletters from Tech Dispenser

Attend Microsoft's Windows 7 Virutal Event for a change to win a Microsoft Zune HD. Register Now!

Register for more Windows Enterprise Webcasts today.

Build a smart, practical path to the internal cloud.

Selecting the Right Reporting Technology

An IT Leadership Action Plan for the Economic Recovery

Consolidate data centers and lower IT service costs. Learn How.

WAN optimization techniques significantly improve application performance. Read More.

The Revolution and Evolution of Private Cloud Computing

March 31st Webcast: "Product Development and the Cross-Functional Team"

Get to know Supermicro. Business-optimized server solutions.

Google Webinar: Why Cloud-Based Security and Archiving Make Sense

Midsized company CIOs and experts connect at infoBOOM!

Core" i5 vPro" Processor: Control meets cost savings in the most intelligent PC processors ever!

Article: The Dynamic Virtual Client offers thin client advantages with rich client user experience & mobility.

Counting Up the End User Benefits of Desktop Virtualization

Simplifying Risk Management: Is Your Company Measuring Up?

Does your IDS really work? Find out with a free Endace Audit

CA ARCserve r12.5 is More Than Backup! Download Trial Version Today

Verint Systems. Discover the Power of Intelligence in Action"

Enterprise search helps employees get more done. Get the facts from Google.

Best Practices to Reduce IT Operational Costs

Real-world testing ranks Trend Micro #1 against malware. See results.

Efficiency goes up. Costs come down.

Dark Fiber from Sunesys Save on Unlimited Bandwidth with Fixed Costs.

Trend Micro ranked #1 against real-world malware. Read more.

Get ready for your Windows 7 upgrade at this live, virtual event. Register Now!

Entrust IdentityGuard  Strong Authentication for your Enterprise

How Healthcare CIOs Achieve a High-Performance Emergency Department

Webcast: Solve Your Data Visualization Needs with Open Source BI

Webcast: Delivering the Enterprise-Ready Cloud

Ensure cost effective application delivery. Learn More.

Cloud Computing: The Impact CIOs See

What's New in SOA Suite 11g?