Nick Carr continues his assault on IT organizations in his latest book, "The Big Switch." Unlike his previous book, "Does IT Matter," however, in this book traditional IT is a wounded bystander, casually winged by Carr while he takes aim at his major target, which is the move to a centralized, webified information processing infrastructure.

I criticized "Does IT Matter" because it denigrated IT due to its inability to provide permanent competitive advantage to companies. I felt that Carr took down a straw man since no capability, whether IT, basic research, innovative marketing, or clever recruiting, can provide sustained competitive advantage. In a capitalist economy, there's always someone coming after you, often by adapting your distinct advantage; consequently, competitive advantage is fleeting, no matter what its basis. Carr's dominant metaphor for discussing this lack of competitive advantage was the rise and role of railroads, which, while interesting, was (to my mind) not directly applicable, since railroads don't have a Moore's Law underpinning them, enabling constant exponential functionality improvement.

Carr continues his intriguing use of historical antecedents in "The Big Switch," with the primary example being the move to centralized electrical utilities from the original Edison vision of neighborhood-based generating stations. Likewise, Carr argues, computing is moving from company-based data centers to large utility computing infrastructures run by the likes of infrastructure providers (e.g., Amazon and its EC2 offering) and centralized services run by application providers (e.g., Google Applications).

Carr devotes no more than a few paragraphs to the role of IT organizations in this new centralized computing world, observing that IT organizations will be superseded by end user organizations taking computing into their own hands, aided by the availability of centralized utilities and applications.

I enjoyed reading the book very much, and am impressed by Carr's ability to draw on historical developments to vividly depict the role of new technology developments in changing people's lives. In the section on the move to power utilities, he describes the role of Samuel Insull in creating power companies; I had heard of Insull before but was not acquainted with his important role in creating the electrified society we live in. Likewise, Carr describes an early mega-water wheel, used to deliver competitive advantage to a company, later discarded in favor of centralized utility for factory power, which provided the inspiration for George Ferris when constructing his new contraption, the Ferris Wheel. Carr's ability to weave together these events and people makes for an entertaining and informative read.

The second half of the book goes in a different direction, though. Having described the advantages of centralized computing, Carr begins to methodically outline its drawbacks: identity tracking, wrenching economic change as cheap content undermines traditional media businesses, community polarization as people increasingly turn to ideologically slanted web offerings, terrorists and rogue nations using cyberwar to attack our web-based economies, and, perhaps worst of all, government agencies and corporations using massive data capabilities to strip individuals of power and freedom. Carr closes by discussing the potential for computing to outstrip humans and become our master through artificial intelligence. In a way, the theme of the book seems to be a jeremiad about the future role of information technology in the world.

I found the book to be, ultimately, dissatisfying. Carr seems to have a curiously schizophrenic attitude toward IT: dismissing it in one book, decrying its omnipotence in another. In "The Big Switch" Carr does seem to grasp hold of the concept of Moore's Law, which is continuously driving new capabilities in the use of IT; however, he seems to focus on all the downside with much less appreciation of the positive developments offered

You do not have flash or javascript support.

Average (1 vote)

Reply
Digg this
Slashdot
Reddit
LinkedIn