NEWSLETTERS
 

CIO.com updates, insights and advice on technology, management and your career.

 Advice and Opinion

 CIO Consumer IT

 CIO Leader

 CIO Enterprise

 CIO Insider

 

RSS Feeds »

 
 
SUBSCRIBE TO CIO
 

Are you involved in setting the direction for your company's IT budget or strategy?

Apply today for a FREE subscription to CIO Magazine!

» Subscription Services

» Reprints

 

 


Fri, Mar 21, 2008 15:13 EDT

Hardcore Facebook Fans Join Apple and Linux Boosters as the Most Vicious

Topic: Applications

Blog: Information Collective

Current Rating: 5 Comments: 3

I used to think Apple and Linux fanboys detested the business press most, perhaps due to what they perceive as a lack of understanding about their technologies of choice.

But after watching the video of last week’s excruciatingly painful keynote between Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg and BusinessWeek reporter Sarah Lacy at the South by Southwest Interactive Festival, it led me to believe that Facebook fans have happily joined the ranks of technology’s most venomous fans.

If you haven’t heard, here’s what happened. For Zuckberberg’s keynote appearance, the conference organizers decided that a Q&A format would be better than a speech. By the end of the discussion (you can see the full video on Justin Smith's blog here), the fans in the audience, many of whom were Facebook application developers, felt that Lacy had become too chummy with the young CEO. They started cackling at her to "ask something interesting!"

It gave way to a mob mentality of faceless Facebook fanboys screaming at her, and the talk spiraled out of control.

While Lacy’s questions were at times remarkably self-indulgent (or sometimes not questions at all), and it was annoying how she repeatedly went out of her way to note that she had spent time with Zuckerberg to write a book about him, the Facebook fans' behavior at this incident seemed over the top. Moreover, it revealed the friction between journalists who cover technology, and hardcore enthusiasts who read their stories and watch their interviews.

This friction has played out on the web during the past few years as both the trade and mainstream press opened up their sites to user-generated content. Up to now, it's been especially vicious in the world of the Linux operating system and Apple products.

Here's a couple examples that should elucidate the point:

On CIO.com last summer, a freelancer wrote a story called Eight Reasons Not To Use Linux in the Enterprise. The resulting comment thread by Linux aficionados descended into character assassination, with personalized critiques of the author and his sources. Essentially, they contended he was nothing but a Microsoft lackey who hated open-source.

Apple fans have also gotten into the fun more recently with the iPhone for business announcement. Wall Street Journal reporter Ben Worthen wrote an interesting blog post in the wake of the iPhone SDK launch after he interviewed a Forrester Research analyst that raised some interesting questions about the iPhone as a device suitable for business. Of course, the fanboys argued ridiculously, Worthen must have been on the payroll of BlackBerry maker Research in Motion.

The Facebook Q&A, to me, was like watching these types of comment threads play out in person.

In my mind, there’s a few reasons for this rocky relationship between the media and the fanboys.

One is spineless web-rage. The ability for fanboys to post anonymously, or, in this case, to shout like mongrels from the middle of a conference venue, has allowed them to cross the line into being downright disrespectful while hiding behind their strength in numbers.

Secondly, collective intelligence (as spawned by user generated content and social technologies) and the mob mentality aren’t one and the same, and these fanboys have frequently opted for the latter. They go after the messenger rather than the actual facts. If the journalist says or writes something that displeases them or is construed as slighting their technology (or hero) of choice in any sort of way, they lose it (and usually go over the top, because you can tell they enjoy the sport of it).

The last issue: a great many business journalists, often concerned

You do not have flash or javascript support.
Average (2 votes)
5
 
 
Fri, Mar 21, 2008 23:39 EDT
Anonymous user
Posted by: Tom
Rating:

I believe Linux is "the best" for a variety of reasons and advocate for my favorite flavors on a regular basis (e.g. Ubuntu which is Linux for those who fear the Penguin) What I don't do is deride Microsoft (their operating systems have kept me employed for years) nor do I attack people who dislike Linux or post negative things about it.

Rather than rant at and about people who rant, why not simply ask them to behave civilly? If they refuse, technology is available to filter them in cyberspace and in meatspace, nice police officers are always helpful with the unruly.

 
Sat, Mar 22, 2008 1:22 EDT
Anonymous user
Posted by: Rodney Rumford
Rating:

I think the real issue was they had the wrong person for the interview. Very Unfortunate. Seriously, you have a chance to interview the CEO of the hottest tech company in the valley and you don't ask hard questions? Blown opportunity.

I think that she should have been better prepared and asked more pertinent questions. If you see the interview she did after the train wreck, she still maintains that SHE did nothing wrong.

The funny thing is, the crowd got hostile because they had a hunger for knowledge about technology and what is coming. They lost their patience when she never got past the self serving chit-chat.

As a side note: no one is anonymous on twitter. ;)

You can see more on my thoughts on this as well as the video clip of her post interview here:
http://facereviews.com/2008/03/09/zuckerberg-interviewer-denies-train-wreck-shes-clueless/

Cheers!

Rodney Rumford
Editor: FaceReviews.com

 
Sat, Mar 29, 2008 5:02 EDT
Anonymous user
Posted by: slgr
Rating:

I think your interpretation of things is somewhat mistaken. I think the real trend is that technology people of all sorts hate whitewashing, they hate obfuscation, they hate vague misinformation, and they hate the superficial. With all the articles and events you cite, it's pretty clear.
With the reasons to not use Linux article, there was far too much generalization and no nuance. As an example, I used to work in IT and the entity I was employed by essentially paid hundreds of thousands of dollars in license costs to make XP behave more like linux: They paid to get software analogous to a linux package manager, such as apt or emerge to maintains software on their linux boxes, and it took them at least a year to even figure out how to get it set up and working. They also had to expend the energy to redo the users on every system so that there was effective user privilege escalation... essentially a ton of time to make a poor analogue of sudo. Then there were tons of little things. As an example,(I'll admit I don't know if there's some sort of alternative way to do this) changing from one print server to another that ran maybe 30 printers on 3 floors, they had each printer manually added via wizard to the new server. Time consuming and tedious. And I'd bet money with linux you could have just copied a config file from the old one to the new one. So essentially, when I have experiences such as that, only brushing the surface, and then I read an article that overgeneralize about 'linux' instead of pointing out issues with specific distros (such as how annoying yum is on Fedora), it's annoying.

Much the same way, people from a community of some kind don't like lowest common denominator reporting. They're used to being able to change the community with their voices, being taken seriously, and given some respect. The Larry King treatment isn't going to pass muster with them. So when Facebook guy gets interviewed, the people there don't want their questions wasted.

Apple, too, is often subject to a lot of mischaracterization. I meet professional people fairy often who hear about macs and then start talking about problems from the days of Mac OS 8 or sometimes oven Mac OS 7 like the same problems are still around. The worst part is that some people come up with mac issues that have never existed.

It is my opinion that better informed individuals from respective communities, be they the Linux community, the Facebook community, or the Apple community, often get subjected to stupid mischaracterizations by a broader society that doesn't really understand things at the same level they do, and these mischaracterizations only create impetus for a sense of needing to inform of the truth. And, unfortunately, there are 2 layers of truth, One is that there are often simplification, near falsehoods, and misstatements up the wazoo in mainstream articles relating to Mac, the Internet, and Linux. It is one thing to correct them. But the second layer of truth is that the reason there are so many poor articles on these topics is that the individuals who write on them are often not qualified enough, competent enough, or knowledgeable enough to do so accurately. I hardly think it should come as a surprise that people become more radicalized and pissed over time after time of being subjected to the phenomenon.

About this Blog

Tips, hints, and interesting tidbits for information technology professionals as collected by the editorial staff of CIO.

Start a Conversation

Click to post

Got something to say? We want to hear it! Click the Post button to get started. GO»

EXPERT ADVICE

See our roster of experts.

Advice & Opinion from more than 77 of IT's most insightful thinkers.

advertisement

TOP USERS
UserPoints
1. laith al jazi12550
2. Akshay Upadhye7650
3. Chris Moore6750
4. abdhiraj6175
5. remi5325
UserPoints
6. asengupta3750
7. tmmackay3500
8. Sureshram3125
9. Michael Kavis2950
10. mtruxaw2900
  PARTNERS       PODCASTS       WEBCASTS    
 

Enterprise Content Management: From Strategy to Solution

Enterprise content management (ECM) has become an important competence and infrastructural technology, particularly for large and medium-sized organizations. Hear about industry trends for ECM and why standardizing your ECM platform is so critical to your success during this roundtable discussion.

Sponsored by IBM  View This Webcast »

 

Get Rich or Get Thin: The Secure Client Webcast

Malcolm Harkins, General Manager of Intel's Information Risk and Security group, looks at the increasing sophistication of attacks. He also talks about he pros and cons of thin and rich clients in fending off those attacks.

Sponsored by Intel
  View This Webcast »

 

The Greening of the Data Center

This report outlines a four-part strategy companies can employ to achieve an energy-efficient infrastructure.

Sponsored by Sepaton  Read this White Paper »

More Partners »

Resource Alerts

Get instant email notifications by topic when white papers, webcasts, and case studies are added to our library.

Podcast: Accenture's View on Software as a Service

Publisher Emeritus at CIO magazine, Gary Beach, talks to Accenture Chief Architect, Paul Daugherty, about where software is going, and in particular about the emerging concept of software as a service and its contribution to high performance.   Read More »

 

Business Service Management: Delivering Value Throughout the Service Lifecycle

Business and IT alignment is as much a priority among CIOs, as it is a challenge...  Read More »

 

Talking Innovation with a Hall of Famer

Bill Walsh, lauded for his innovative thinking on the football field, talks techniques for applying innovation to every job.  Read More »

More Podcasts »

Resource Alerts

Get instant email notification when white papers, webcasts, and case studies are added to our library. Don't just be up-to-date—be up to the minute with our new Resource Alerts.

Crossing The Data Divide: The Case For Complex Data Exchange Technology

Hear the results of a new study conducted by IDG examining how to maximize the value of your enterprise information assets by automating the data exchange process. Join now and learn how technology can help you Cross The Data Divide.   Read More »

 

Collaborative Resiliency: A Unified Approach to Risk Management

Climate change, oil price shock, pandemic and acts of terrorism are true risks that cannot be ignored...  Read More »

 

The Great Escape: Contact Center Applications Are Moving into the Enterprise

With resulting benefits such as tighter integration with back-office applications, administrative control, and improved communications, contact center applications are moving into the enterprise. In this webcast...  Read More »

More Webcasts »

Resource Alerts

Get instant email notification when white papers, webcasts, and case studies are added to our library. Don't just be up-to-date—be up to the minute with our new Resource Alerts.

 
NEWSLETTER

Sign-up for the Advice & Opinion Newsletter

 
FEATURED SPONSORS
 
 
 
SPONSORED LINKS
 

A CIO's View of Server Virtualization

Survival of the Fittest: Disaster Recovery Design for the Data Center

Windows Server 2008: To Upgrade or Not to Upgrade?

How Office 2007 Exposed Bill Gates

How to simplify mobility and reduce the cost of supporting mobile workers

Helping IT Become a Service Provider White Paper

Extending PCI Compliance to the Mobile Workforce

A proven approach to WAN optimization

Wireless Vulnerability Management: What It Means for Your Enterprise

Green IT: Reducing Your Carbon Footprint with Citrix

Wide-area data services enable todays global enterprise

Discover PMI's credentials and career path tools

Symantec State of the Data Center Report

Getting the Most from your Data Protection Solution

Tripwire PCI DSS Solutions: Automated, Continuous Compliance

ITCi White Paper: Challenges and Opportunities of PCI

TDWI Research report clears confusion about automating data governance

White Paper: Unlocking the Potential of B2B

See why 93 of the Fortune Global 100 depend on Blue Coat.

Taking Document Automation to the Next Level

Video Series: IT Leaders discuss how IT is becoming part of the innovation cycle.

How Plug-in Integration with Global Suppliers Quickly Multiplies the Value of SAP Investments

White Paper: WebMethods Business Process Management Suite

Webcast: A look at the increasing sophistication of attacks

Model, Execute, and Optimize: Oracle Fusion Middleware and the BPM Lifecycle

Enterprise Service Bus: A Definition

Let's Get Virtual: A Look at Today's Server Virtualization Architectures

Increase conversions on your site with the help of EV SSL.

Get Control of Mobile Data (and More)

Data Loss Prevention Starts at the Endpoint

Building a Foundation for Pragmatic Service Management White Paper

Performance Brief: Mobile Application Acceleration

Strategies for centralizing data backup

Citrix XenServer FREE trial

Nothing Short of Revolutionary: Four Steps toward More Effective Enterprise Finance

The Best IT Strategy for a Company with Global Operations

Speed, agility, flexibility - The HP BladeSystem c-Class

The Business Value of Symantec Data Center Foundation Solutions

Webcast: Why standardizing your ECM platform is so critical to your success

The PCI Data Security Standard

White Paper: Assess Your SOA

The Universal Wireless Client: Simplify mobility and reduce the cost of supporting mobile workers

Tuning ERP and the Supply Chain for Profitable Growth

Compliance by the numbers- addressing requirements with online document management and collaboration technology

Webcast: Learn how to Simplify and Standardize Architecture

Research about the efficiencies created by different operating systems.

Shift your ERP investments into high gear and join the leaders!

White Paper: Intel IT testing of select multi-core processors results

IDC VP Carl Olofson Reviews Technology Advances and How to Handle Reporting and Querying

People, Processes, and SOA: Oracle Fusion Middleware and the Responsive Enterprise