Apply today for a FREE subscription to CIO Magazine!
Fri, Dec 7, 2007 14:57 EST

|
Posted by: Esther Schindler in News Topic: InfrastructureBlog: You're the Boss
Current Rating: |
A group of die-hard OS/2 users are petitioning IBM—again—to release the operating system's source code as open-source. The question may not be whether IBM wants to do so... but if it can. Not, I expect, that IBM will actually say this out loud.
I have some skin in this game. Or, rather, I have a lot of scrapes and bruises, and a few scars. For some years, I bet my career on OS/2: writing books (savvy readers will recall my recent mention of Teach Yourself Rexx in 21 Days), magazine articles (there was a solid chance that any tech article you read about OS/2 had my byline), teaching classes about OS/2 to corporate users, and as an activist in OS/2 user groups. I'm a Certified OS/2 Engineer. Until I moved into my new house, three years ago, I had the world's largest collection of native OS/2 applications—something over 300 of them, including a few that never saw the light of day. Yeah, I cared. I still care.
At a Comdex in the late 90s, I was in the press room chatting with three other computer industry journalists who had also written quite a bit about the OS. Jerry Pournelle wandered by. "Hey, Jerry," said Wayne. "We were just talking about OS/2." Jerry nodded and said, "Yeah, OS/2. Great operating system, with only one problem—"
And we all shouted in unison, "IBM!"
Everyone who tried it loved OS/2, especially OS/2 Warp. Technically, it was a wonderful operating system. It really multitasked. It was robust; yet, the OS would shoot itself before it would permit harm to come to a byte of your data. It had an attractive, truly object-oriented GUI (for its time; OS/2 2.0 screen shots make me wince, today). Sure, it had some technology weaknesses (I'm certain I can out-geek you on the details); but OS/2 was far superior to its competition. For me, at least, it was the first OS to achieve the Principle of Least Astonishment: when I didn't know how to do something, my first guess was generally correct. (Mac OS X later exceeded in this principle; after several years of using Windows XP, I still spend five minutes looking for the simplest things.)
But you'll note that I said technically. Between Microsoft's business behavior (&deity had better give me extra credit for that diplomatic phrase), IBM's inept marketing (which caused me to shout unprofessionally at perfectly nice IBMers who lacked the power to change things), and a computer press who'd been burned by OS/2 1.0 and believed Microsoft's as-yet-unreleased Windows 95 would be far superior (because, after all, vaporware has no bugs) — well, technical superiority didn't win.
OS/2 did get a new breath of life when IBM OEM'ed it to eComStation (eCS), which coincidentally has version 2.0 in beta. eCS is targeted primarily at enterprises that still rely on OS/2 for legacy software but need it to run on more modern equipment; yet, it still has a die-hard community of end-users who run eCS/OS/2 as their primary OS.
Anyhow. As I said, the committed OS/2 community sent a petition to IBM two years ago, with 11,613 signatures, asking the company to release the OS/2 source code (or whatever part IBM owns) under an open source license. "Sadly, IBM was ignorant enough to not answer our first letter, and this is why we sent a second letter to IBM," wrote Kim
Here at Metztli Information technology, we believe that the open sourcing of the OS/2 code would be a positive addition to the open standards inherent in Open Source Software (OSS).
I would like nothing more than to think that this time the petition might work or, at the very least, IBM would step up and publicly say no. My money is on no reply at all. Why revisit something that represents a period when IBM was slowly falling apart and being displaced my Microsoft? Why step up and say no in front of the open source crowd, showing their true colors?
I did sign the petition, again. It is just a shame that the source that took so much time and effort to produce will just cease to exist. What a waste.
MikeG
I don't think IBM will even respond to the request because they have no concept what a user might be let alone a user community. A large corporation, its CIO and decision makers are the only people that matter to IBM because they are the only people they have ever dealt with. If one phones IBM, you need to have a customer number or at least a rep number otherwise you don't exist and don't know how to cope with you. To get their interest, you need to represent millions in business volume otherwise you simply don't exist in their eyes. IBM is strictly a corporation oriented company and can't understand or deal with anything else. They are at ease with a single contract involving thousands of items or licenses with its maintenance but not interested in selling millions of individual copies to consumers. IBM's business culture is very peculiar and can be difficult for most to understand.
I think that a lot of OS/2 users don't get this, Gilbert. IBM has tried many times to sell to "users" rather than to corporations, but it's never figured out the knack of it. Every time they try—OS/2, speech recognition software, multimedia and ISDN cards—they stumble. They stumble even more spectacularly when they get fans. They don't know how to deal with fans.
And like a race car that's tuned to drive on the Autobahn at 120mph, the company is far less successful when they try to drive at "normal" speeds. Such as selling or supporting even smaller corporations. An issue discussed elsewhere, here at CIO, in What If Yoda Ran IBM?".
I would also like to add that IBM has a large business partner ecosystem in place for driving at "normal" speeds. Accordingly, those IBM Business Partners worldwide implement the IBM interface at a local level and enable the Small to Medium Business (SMB) market to interact with Big Blue.
IBM, through partners like us at Metztli IT, even offers robust free or low cost entry level products for SMBs. As a noteworthy example of a no cost SMB product that is viable on OS/2 is the WebSphere Application Server Community Edition (WASCE) versions 1.x