NEWSLETTERS
 

CIO.com updates, insights and advice on technology, management and your career.

 CIO BlackBerry News and Tips
 CIO Research and Analysis
 CIO Microsoft
 CIO Insider
 
 
 
SUBSCRIBE TO CIO
 
Are you involved in setting the direction for your company's IT budget or strategy?

Apply today for a FREE subscription to CIO Magazine!

 


Tue, Nov 3, 2009 7:44 EST

Home Depot vs. Trevor Keezer and The God Squad

Does our right to free speech apply to the workplace? Nope.

Topic: Personal Management

Blog: Career Connection

Current Rating: 2 Comments: 13

Trevor Keezer told the Associated Press that he was fired from his job as a cashier at The Home Depot on October 23, 2009, for wearing a pin on his orange apron that expressed his religious beliefs. The pin featured a picture of Old Glory and contained the following words from the Pledge of Allegiance: "…one nation, under God… INDIVISIBLE."

He’d been wearing the pin since March 2008 to support his brother, a soldier in Iraq, and to show his love for God and country, Keezer said. (See the AP story for additional details.)

A spokesperson for The Home Depot explained to the AP that Keezer was let go for violating the company's dress code. Keezer declined to wear a patriotic pin that store management had offered to him, the spokesperson said. Home Depot's sanctioned pin read, "United We Stand."

Keezer's attorney notes that her client was fired shortly after he started bringing a Bible to work so that he could read it on breaks. She plans to sue Atlanta-based Home Depot for religious discrimination.

Why religious discrimination and not violation of her client’s Constitutional right to free speech? Michael Masinter, a law professor at Nova Southeastern University in Fort Lauderdale, Fla., says that free speech provisions in the First Amendment only limit the government's power, not private citizens or corporations.  

"While it is true that the First Amendment prevents the government from restricting your freedom of speech, it does not prevent The Home Depot or any private citizen or entity from imposing limits upon what can be said on their property," Masinter says. "There is no freedom of speech under the U.S. Constitution that applies in the private workplace."

The fact that Americans' freedom of speech isn't protected by the Constitution in the workplace must have come as a shock to Keezer. In an interview with Fox News, Keezer said, "I don't see how it's American to make me take off a pin that represents so much." After all, freedom and democracy is what his brother is fighting for in Iraq.

While the Constitution may not protect Americans' right to free speech in the workplace, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 does protect them from racial, sexual and religious discrimination in hiring, promotions and discharges, says Masinter. That’s why Keezer's attorney is fighting his termination on the grounds of anti-discrimination laws.

The question the court will have to decide: Was Trevor Keezer fired for his religious beliefs, or because he refused to follow his employer's dress code?

Masinter says religious discrimination may be tough to prove on the basis of the pin alone because the message on the pin could be seen as more of a political statement than a religious one. "If it's a political statement, there is no law that protects his right to make that statement," says the law professor, adding that wearing the pin is not like wearing a yarmulke if you're an Orthodox Jew or a cross if you're an observant Christian.  

The blog Incertus argues that Keezer brought the firing upon himself by refusing to remove his button. The sanctimonious pundits at Fox News, on the other hand, have thrown their support Keezer's way and all but called for a boycott of Home Depot for firing such a principled, patriotic worker.

Regardless of what side you're on,


You do not have flash or javascript support.
Average (1 vote)
2
 
 
Wed, Nov 4, 2009 9:39 EST
Anonymous user
Posted by: Anonymous
Rating: 90

Pull your head out Meredith! Who are you to decide that Trevor's is not a religious statement? The fact that he brought a bible to work should lay that argument to rest. It's not like Trevor did anything malicious or violated someone ele's rights. Home Depot needs to pull its head out too, else many of us won't be shopping there anymore. Would intelligent management try to make a case out of nothing?

 
Wed, Nov 4, 2009 10:08 EST
Anonymous user
Posted by: Anonymous
Rating: 80

If Home Depot doesn't restrict their employees from what they can and can't wear or display on their clothes, then where does it stop. Would it be okay to wear a pin that supports abortion/pro choice, a democrat/republican, etc.. I'm a christian and I don't support Keezer. But I do support going to work and doing your job. I'll continue to shop at Home Depot.

 
Wed, Nov 4, 2009 10:53 EST
Posted by: Phil Murphy
Rating: 90

Anonymous completely misses the point - Home Depot has rules about what people may wear. Keezer could have worn Home Depot's "United We Stand" pin to support his brother in Iraq (remember him), but he refused. Keezer took an employment issue - on which he would clearly lose based on its merits - and attempted to insert a religious thread into it for the press maelstrom he knew it would create.

Keezer repeatedly violated Home Depot's employment rules with the goal of fomenting religious activists to battle the dress code in a commercial establishment - a place where religion has no place. When the pin alone didn't raise enough press attention, he upped the ante by bringing in a bible to bolster his weak claim that the dress code issue was religious in nature - thereby forcing Home Depot's hand. Keezer's actions underscore how disingenuous he truly is and what a grandstanding ploy this truly is. That is the larger issue.

The encroachment by religious zealots (of all kinds) on the rights of everyday citizens has reached a breaking point. The zealots interpret "freedom of religion" as their right to force-feed us their brand of religious dogma at every turn - in schools, malls, stores, and restaurants. Enough! Freedom of religion also includes freedom FROM religion. This country was founded by people who fled religious intolerance that was so insidious in England at the time due to the establishment of a single state-sanctioned religion. We're not a Christian nation, we are a nation that includes Christians, Jews, Muslims, Shinto, Buddhists, Taoists, Native American and Wicca among many others and also the views of agnostics and athiests. Keezer and Anonymous would have us repeat those mistakes hundreds of years later. So to all the Keezer-ites out there, I say - keep your religious views and dogma at your home and place of worship, don't worry about what I believe - it's none of your business. I'll do the same, and there will be more peace in the world.

If the Keezer-ites like Anonymous want to boycott Home Depot - I say good riddance. The type of majority-rules-tyranny and financial leverage you threaten is exactly the type of behavior our forefathers fled in England as this country was born. "Might makes right" / "Strength in numbers" is not justice, it is a "my way or the highway" approach whose time has past.

As to Keezer - he sought and got his 15 minutes of fame, don't waste more publicity on him.

 
Wed, Nov 4, 2009 11:34 EST
Anonymous user
Posted by: Anonymous
Rating: 50

There is a lot of the legal side of this that is missing. Without it, many will rush to conclusions. In a suit against a corporation, the most damning evidence that can be brought is evidence of a manager ignoring policy or not enforcing it uniformly. If Mr. Keezer wore the button for an extended period of time even if it is in violation of company standards, the manager has the responsibility to enforce the standard. Failure of enforcement by the manager would grant Mr. Keezer an exemption from the rule and set a dangerous precedent.

It will also depend on any formal disciplinary action taken by his manager - verbal/written warnings, etc. - to show that he was following company policy for discipline and terminated as per that policy. What we don't know is anything regarding that procedure and its timing with bringing a Bible to work.

If the manager followed company procedure in disciplining Mr. Keezer, he will lose the case because it will be an employment contract issue, not a discrimination suit. If the manager failed to follow policy, however, it will be very hard for the company to defend the incidental(?) timing of the termination.

 
Wed, Nov 4, 2009 22:14 EST
Anonymous user
Posted by: just me
Rating: 10

If it is company policy, why haven't they fired several in different stores where I shop who have all kinds of buttons and pins on their HD aprons ?

Post new comment

* Subject:
* Username:
* E-mail:
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Homepage:
* Body:
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <blockquote> <strike> <p> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
More information about formatting options

* Denotes required field.

About this Blog

Insight and advice to help you carve your way in the cut-throat business world today.

Start a Conversation
Click to post

Got something to say? We want to hear it! Click the Post button to get started. GO»

EXPERT ADVICE
See our roster of experts.

Advice & Opinion from more than 113 of IT's most insightful thinkers.

  PARTNERS       WEBCASTS    
 

Windows 7 Webcast Series

There's a lot of buzz about Windows 7 out there. Each month in our webcast series, listen to analysts and customers discuss how Windows 7 and the Windows Optimized Desktop is impacting large companies around the world. Learn how they evaluated Windows 7, including the cost of deployment, deployment strategies, and tangible benefits.

Sponsored by Microsoft  Listen to on-demand Recordings »

 

Service Level Management Best Practices Life Cycle Overview - Improve Service Levels

Best practices for Service Level Management (SLM) is a process for consistently meeting customer requirements and delivering on IT's promises. See the steps required to ensure high-quality SLM.

Sponsored by Compuware  Read this White Paper »

 

Keeping Your Members Safe from Online Scams and Predators

In order to keep fraudsters out, romance sites must deploy effective solutions that look at information independent of what is supplied by users. A device fingerprinting solution such as iovation ReputationManager™ provides unique insight into the computers being used to create multiple accounts and exposes hidden device-account relationships that identity-based fraud solutions often miss.

Sponsored by iovation  Read this White Paper »

Resource Alerts

Get instant email notifications by topic when white papers, webcasts, and case studies are added to our library.

Resource Alerts

Get instant email notification when white papers, webcasts, and case studies are added to our library. Don't just be up-to-date—be up to the minute with our new Resource Alerts.

Defend Against Blended Threats: What You Need to Know

Blended Web and email threats are becoming increasingly complex and represent a huge...  View Now »

 

Prescriptive Actions to Reduce Risk

In this Webcast, learn best practices for effective systems management in a heterogeneous environment and keep client systems cost under control.   View Now »

 

Webcast- Vantage 11: Redefining Application Performance Management

Compuware's latest release, Vantage 11, is a major advance in end-to-end application performance management--bringing together proactive issue identification, quantification of business impact and problem resolution into a single solution. Tune in to learn how Vantage 11's top-down approach helps you make better decisions and dramatically lower operations costs.  View Now »

Resource Alerts

Get instant email notification when white papers, webcasts, and case studies are added to our library. Don't just be up-to-date—be up to the minute with our new Resource Alerts.

 
NEWSLETTER

Sign-up for the Blogs & Discussion Newsletter

 
FEATURED SPONSORS
 
 
 
SPONSORED LINKS
 

Return on Information: Google Enterprise Search pays you back. Get the facts.

VMware. The source for Business Infrastructure Virtualization.

ShoreTel tells businesses to untangle from competitors' complexity and turn to its brilliantly simple UC solution

See how AT&T can help protect your network.

Streamline IT Costs. Boost Performance with WAN Optimization.

Build your 1st app FREE with Force.com

TDWI checklist helps define data readiness for analytics. Download report.

A Clear View Toward Virtualization

Virtualization Technology as a Business Solution

The rules of infrastructure management just changed.

A Clear View Toward Virtualization

Interactive Q&A helps you discover key ways to maximize IT assets.

Ready to virtualize tier one applications? Check your virtualization maturity.

Think you can't afford a Cisco Switch? Cisco Catalyst Switches are now more affordable.

Five minute business analytics assessment. Immediate results.

The Case for Investing in Business Analytics Technology. Read white paper.

Upgrading to VMware vSphere with vWire

Top 10 Lessons Learned for Corporate 3G Mobile Broadband Deployments

CRM Built for IT: The Executive Guide to Selecting CRM that Meets IT Needs

Return on Information: Google Enterprise Search pays you back

ROI of Application Delivery Controllers

Making Consumer Two-Factor Authentication Simple and Cost-Effective

Mining the Cloud to Ease the Enterprise Compliance Burden

Solve Five Key IT Security Challenges with Cloud-Based Authentication

White Paper: Right-Sizing Your Power Infrastructure

AT&T Synaptic Storage as a Service. Expand on demand

Trend Micro ranked #1 against real-world malware. Read more.

Webinar: Jump-start your in-house e-discovery with Ringtail QuickCull from FTI Technology

Top Five CIO Challenges

Read the RSA report: Security for Business Innovation

64-page prescriptive guide to security, compliance, and IT operations.

Increase UPS efficiency without sacrificing protection.

eZine: A Roadmap to Reducing IT Complexity

Reduce risk, gain agility. See how Progress can help your business.

Virtualization Technology as a Business Solution

eZine: A Roadmap to Reducing IT Complexity

World-class trading technology solutions from NYSE Technologies.

If You're Paying for Telecom, You're Paying Too Much. Contact Asentinel Today.

Trade-In your old printer and save up to $1,000 plus free recycling!

infoBOOM! - The Mid-Sized Company CIO's Exclusive Community

Live Webinar: Applying Business Analytics. Click here to learn more

Removing Barriers To Better Server Virtualization Efficiency

4G Revisited. The Continued Evolution of Wireless Mobility.

What's Next for Enterprise Resource Planning?

Maximizing website Return on Information with high-quality search

Gartner Magic Quadrant, Application Delivery Controllers 2009

Authentication as a Service by Forrester Research

Cloud-Based Authentication for Next-Generation Extranets

Cut Costs & Green Your IT Operations with PC Power Management

White Paper: 4 Customer Service Myths