IT DRILLDOWN
 
NEWSLETTERS
 

CIO.com updates, insights and advice on technology, management and your career.

 
 
 
SUBSCRIBE TO CIO
 
Are you involved in setting the direction for your company's IT budget or strategy?

Apply today for a FREE subscription to CIO Magazine!

 

 


Wed, Feb 27, 2008 13:18 EST

How Do You Find Your Next Job?

Topic: Personal Management

Blog: Movers and Shakers

Current Rating: 5 Comments: 2

Would you rather get help from an executive recruiter, or would you rather work directly with the employer? What do you think is the best way to land your next job?

 

IT executives usually land new roles through headhunters, but increasingly, employers are recruiting senior executives—in IT and other functions—on their own.

Sam Gordon, the director of Harvey Nash Executive Search's CIO practice, says companies started searching directly for IT executives after the dot com crash in 2002, when the marketplace was flooded with talented professionals, which made hiring much easier. Gordon says companies continue this practice of "direct recruiting" today—and not just in IT. Gordon's colleagues who recruit for other functions are witnessing the same trend.

Companies have two reasons to hire senior level executives on their own:

  1. It can be cheaper than retaining a search firm.
  2. To beef up their internal talent management and recruiting functions.

Clearly, direct recruiting is a threat to the executive search industry, but I'm wondering if it may be beneficial for IT executives. Would you rather answer an online job ad for a CIO-level position and apply for a position with a company directly, or would you rather work through an executive recruiter? Why? What are the advantages and disadvantages of each?

I've heard a number of CIOs complain about headhunters. They say executive recruiters don't return their phone calls, aren't as interested in networking as they claim to be, only serve as gatekeepers, and only pursue the same group of CIOs for placement. Yet executive recruiters can be an important ally for IT leaders seeking new jobs. Good ones carefully match candidates with opportunities, offer candidates sound advice on their resumes and interviewing techniques, advocate for the candidate and handle dicey salary negotiations.

Would you want to negotiate your salary directly with the individual who was going to be your boss? CIO.com Managing Editor Michael Goldberg likens the question to real estate: Would you rather hire a realtor to sell your house or put up "For Sale By Owner" signs?

There are advantages and disadvantages to both: If you negotiate directly with your boss and take a hard line on the negotiations, you risk looking like a prima donna and potentially alienating yourself from your manager as you start your new job. On the other hand, an executive recruiter who, like a realtor, doesn't want to lose a commission may advise you to fold on tough negotiations when you feel like holding out for more.

Here's another question to consider: Are you comfortable sending your resume to a company through an online portal? What if you never heard back from the company? You're an IT executive, do you think you deserve to get some feedback on your application?

I'm interested in your answers to these many questions, so please share your comments below. Would you rather apply for a job directly or work through a recruiter? Which option do you think increases your chances of getting a job?

Thanks in advance for your feedback!

--Meridith


You do not have flash or javascript support.
Average (2 votes)
5
 
 
Fri, Mar 7, 2008 12:19 EST
Anonymous user
Posted by: Prefbid
Rating:

I'm not sure what an Exec Recruiter even brings to the table for the candidate. I see a lot of advantages for the company, but I see little for the candidate. My admittedly limited experience has been that the recruiter has been helpful in telling me some of the quirks of the company (e.g., how to best dress for the interview) but as soon as the interview was over, I've been told they were required to bow out and that I was on my own to deal with the company for the rest of the process.

Most of the time the exec recruiters have just been an additional screening step that has to be negotiated. A relative few give some feedback which I greatly appreciate. For me negative feedback has been extremely helpful as it tells me that I am reading the job postings wrong or have expressed myself in the wrong way. Most, though, say nothing.

My dilemma becomes one of determining if the recruiting company was actually contracted by the represented company or if they were just fishing for resumes in the hopes of getting an unsolicited commission. As a candidate reading a posting, I can't necessarily tell the difference. Twice I have submitted to an ad, heard absolutely nothing from the head hunter, made the assumption that the headhunter did not actually hold a contract, then went looking for the job by other means. It is not always easy, but I did find the jobs on the corporate web sites. I applied directly and was immediately put on the express interview list. That tells me that I was immanently qualified and that the head hunter was either getting in the way or was just fishing for resumes to present "for a fee".

Sure, if all head hunters operated like the few high quality ones that are out there, then there may be an reason to think that they are helpful. The bad ones make the whole job hunting experience that much harder.

 
Sun, Mar 9, 2008 1:29 EST
Posted by: Mark Cummuta
Rating:

Meridith,

Good questions!!

* Are you comfortable sending your resume to a company through an online portal?
==> I try to avoid sending my resume through general career portals, primarily because its difficult to customize each resume for each application through these sites. Further, many times the company and/or contact person is anonymous, further compounding the issues with industry/company research in order to customize the resume, blocking follow through, etc.

If the application goes through a hiring firm's career portal, I am more comfortable applying electronically. Now that my resume is in their resume database, the upside is that most firms scan that database frequently for potential candidates for new positions. However, there are risks in this direct submission method, as well. First, the resume I submitted is highly customized for a specific opportunity, which means future scans of this same resume will not know of my additional fabulous skills and experiences that make me an ideal candidate for them! Second, my resume still might not get to the initial position's hiring manager for any number of electronic and/or process related reasons. With no feedback for the vast majority of applicants in these electronic processes, we do know of and therefore have no ability to overcome these issues. Third, most recruiters will not consider me for opportunities with that firm for up to 12 months, since most hiring firms will not pay recruiting fees for candidates who are already in their database.

* What if you never heard back from the company? You're an IT executive, do you think you deserve to get some feedback on your application?
==> From my own experience and that of my networking contacts, too often we receive nothing back at all from companies we apply to. This creates a negative impression of these firms by applicants ... individuals who are not only consumers but, when hired again, they will also influence their new employers' purchasing, vendor and partnership decisions.

While I understand the desire or even need for some firms to maintain confidentiality when they need to replace someone, unfortunately the frequent result is that these anonymous ads also eliminate the pressure for HR or hiring managers to provide any kind of response, feedback or status to applicants.

As a recent example, I applied to an anonymous startup firm using their requested method (LinkedIn). Because of my strong interest in this specific opportunity, I went further, spending several days of digging to get past the anonymity. Next, using LinkedIn's electronic referral processes, I initiated two seperate and unique job inquiries through my contacts that appeared to ultimately link directly with the hiring manager, providing both with an introductory letter. At least two of my referrals even sent follow up emails to the hiring manager to make sure he/she had received their info and offering to answer any questions they may have. Finally, I followed up with the anonymous firm and hiring manager by re-applying to the same position two weeks later, with a note that my references should have contacted them on my behalf, and a request for a phone or email response. After an additional 3+ weeks, I still have not heard from this firm or manager.

As an executive, while I expect other executives to treat me with the same level of respect that I offer them, most electronic job portals have earned the "blackhole" stereotype for a reason.

Note to hiring firms - You can gain a clear market advantage by dramatically improving the feedback opportunities throughout your job application processes.

* Would you rather apply for a job directly or work through a recruiter?Which option do you think increases your chances of getting a job?
==> Understandably, in today's economy, many firms would prefer not to pay recruiting fees. Other firms prefer to work through recruiters to gain their expertise, industry contacts, confidentiality, and cost-effective screening processes. Since each firm's preference is unique, personally, I pursue multiple simultaneous channels for leads. Once a lead is identified, I consider all the application options to give me the best possible chance of landing that job, including lead source, firm preference, my skills match, networking opportuntities, recruiter relationships, etc.

If a lead comes from an executive recruiter, then I owe them the respect to work directly through them if I am interested in the position. If I find the lead myself, I have several trusted executive recruiting friends and contacts that I can ping for their opinions, input, ideas, and even internal contacts.

Sometimes the situation warrants requesting a recruiter's assistance to gain the first interview - for example, if they have an exclusive with the firm or have a very strong inside friendship with a key decision maker. Other times these recruiters have advised me to apply directly, again, based on their knowledge of the inside situation of that firm.

Fortunately, I know a number of fantastic executive recruiters who are willing to offset short term gains for long-term strategic benefits. These few have at times used their inside relationships to introduce me directly to hiring managers, not as "the recruiter" but as a networking referral. This is a win-win-win for all concerned, since the firm gains access to a great pre-qualified candidate without a recruiting fee, I gain direct access to a key decision maker along with a knowledgeable referral, and the recruiter gains a stronger relationship with both parties.

Mark Cummuta

About this Blog

The lowdown on new appointments, retirements, job changes and other career moves among IT executives.

Start a Conversation
Click to post

Got something to say? We want to hear it! Click the Post button to get started. GO»

EXPERT ADVICE
See our roster of experts.

Advice & Opinion from more than 90 of IT's most insightful thinkers.

advertisement

TOP USERS
UserPoints
1. laith al jazi12550
2. Akshay Upadhye7650
3. Chris Moore6750
4. abdhiraj6175
5. remi5525
UserPoints
6. Mark Cummuta4950
7. Brian Flora4925
8. Al Sacco4700
9. asengupta3750
10. reCareered3700
  PARTNERS       PODCASTS       WEBCASTS    
 

Enterprise Content Management: From Strategy to Solution

Enterprise content management (ECM) has become an important competence and infrastructural technology, particularly for large and medium-sized organizations. Hear about industry trends for ECM and why standardizing your ECM platform is so critical to your success during this roundtable discussion.

Sponsored by IBM  View This Webcast »

 

The CIO's Guide to Wireless in the Enterprise

This guide provides a basic overview and worksheet of mobile computing for those who are interested in evaluating a wireless enterprise solution.

Sponsored by Blackberry
  Read This White Paper »

 

The Universal Wireless Client

Learn how replacing multiple wireless clients with one Universal Wireless Client can cut support and help desk costs, increase end user satisfaction, improve security, and help implement Network Access Control.

Sponsored by Fiberlink  Read this White Paper »

Resource Alerts

Get instant email notifications by topic when white papers, webcasts, and case studies are added to our library.

NAC launch from HP Procurve Podcast with Lippis Report, Part 1

ProCurve Networking by HP joins the Lippis Report to announce major product and organizational additions to their ProActive Defense strategy.  Read More »

 

Accenture's View on Web 2.0 and its impact on business

Publisher at CIO magazine, Bob Melk, talks to Accenture's Blair Jones about the emergence of Web 2.0...  Read More »

 

A Best-Practice Framework for Virtualization

This podcast offers insights and perspective on the various issues that relate to virtualization...  Read More »

Resource Alerts

Get instant email notification when white papers, webcasts, and case studies are added to our library. Don't just be up-to-date—be up to the minute with our new Resource Alerts.

Forrester builds a case for the next generation information workplace.

As businesses seek new ways to enhance collaboration and improve productivity, the information workplace continues to evolve...  Read More »

 

Find out what Forrester says about mobile endpoint security and its management.

Mobility raises productivity. But IT departments are hard-pressed to protect mobile data and to manage security software, wireless clients and regulatory compliance for mobile workers...   Read More »

 

Get Forrester's take on simplifying mobility with the universal wireless client.

Mobile workers want to use all types of wireless networks: WiFi, 3G cellular networks, corporate WLANs and home wireless networks. But how can IT support...  Read More »

Resource Alerts

Get instant email notification when white papers, webcasts, and case studies are added to our library. Don't just be up-to-date—be up to the minute with our new Resource Alerts.

 
NEWSLETTER

Sign-up for the Advice & Opinion Newsletter

 
FEATURED SPONSORS
 
 
 
SPONSORED LINKS
 

SOA Educational Library at the TIBCO SOA Resource Center

TDWI Report shows strong validation for investing in predictive analytics

Cost-Effective Data Center 1U Server Solutions

Secure your virtual and physical environments with the same software

GET YOUR VoIP ONTM! Win 2 Years of Hosted VoIP from Cypress. $100,000 retail value. Enter today!

Stimulating Innovation: Meeting IT's New Mission

The Struggle to Achieve Agility and Reduce Complexity

Maximizing Site Visitor Trust Using Extended Validation SSL

Standalone Server vs. Open Source Toolkits

Drive More Effective Business Processes with SOA

Oracle Database 11g: Real Application Testing & Manageability

InfoWorld Test Center on Oracle Real Application Testing

Oracle Database 11g: Advances in Compression, Real Application Testing and Data Guard

Getting Off on the Right Foot: Avoiding Common Master Data Management False Starts

Conquering Information Management Challenges

The Challenge of Network Access Control -- Is a Managed Service the Answer?

Efficient by design: Watch this flash demo of the Quad-Core AMD Opteron Processor

HP and Oracle deploy unbreakable computing infrastructure at Replacements, Ltd.

The Universal Wireless Client: Simplify mobility and reduce the cost of supporting mobile workers

Strategic IT Financial Management - Achieve Higher Organizational Performance

Strategies for Asia-Pacific Expansion

Unified Communications: "More Than Just Talk"

Accelerating ITIL at the Service Desk

New research validates telepresence solutions.

The Gartner Magic Quadrant

Video: 21st Century Networking for a 12th Century Castle

Speed, agility, flexibility - The HP BladeSystem c-Class

Learn about the software-based VoIP solution from Microsoft

Microsoft System Center - Designed For Big

Protecting Data in a Highly Networked World

Consolidation: Just the Starting Point for Virtualization

How the Mac is Becoming an IT Standard in the Enterprise

Storage Efficiency: The Key to Green Storage Operation

Fuel the Responsive Enterprise Through Oracle Fusion Middleware

Balance Your Innovation and Efficiency Platforms for Competitive Advantage and Responsiveness

Oracle Real Application Testing with Oracle Database 11g

InfoWorld Test Center on Oracle Active Data Guard

Master Data Management: The Approach Determines the Results

The Power of Pervasive Business Intelligence

Reap the Benefits of Unified Communications

Controlling High Fraud Risk of International Transactions

Renowned Engineering Institution Chooses AMD Processor-Based Servers

How to Manage the Mobile Work Environment

Extending PCI Compliance to the Mobile Workforce

Solving Online Credit Fraud Using Device Reputation

Process Integration and Traceability through Requirements Management

Virtual Support Technology Delivers Quantifiable Gains in Productivity and Performance

Building Competitive Advantage with Next-Generation Wireless Infrastructure

Building an Online Customer Experience Competency

Skechers, an IBM Customer Case Study