Rants
Questions
Soapbox
Best Practices
Apply today for a FREE subscription to CIO Magazine!
Tue, Jul 14, 2009 14:26 EDT

|
Posted by: Meridith Levinson in Questions Topic: Personal ManagementBlog: Career Connection
Current Rating: |
Recently, I set out to report a story on unconventional job interview questions. My theory was that it's tougher for hiring managers to decide who to hire now, when the market is flooded with so many qualified candidates, so hiring managers need to ask more wacky, personal or curveball-type questions during job interviews to help them determine who's best.
I asked IT hiring managers, CIO job seekers and a recruiter to share the unconventional job interview questions they ask or have been asked. They cited a few, which I share below, but on the whole I found that IT hiring managers ask pretty standard questions. The hiring managers and CIO job seekers I interviewed for my story said that they didn't think that the labor market was prompting hiring managers to ask unconventional job interview questions. They did express amazement that some of the standard interview questions still cause IT job seekers to trip up. (Consequently, I had to reposition my story as IT Job Seekers: Can You Answer an Interviewer's 12 Gotcha Questions?)
The "unusual" interview questions that didn't make it into my story:
1. If you could be a super hero, which one would you be?
Simon Stapleton, chief innovation officer at an insurance company based in the U.K., says he was once asked this question, and it caught him off guard. He says he had no idea why the hiring manager asked it, other than to get to know his personality. Stapleton says he told the hiring manager he'd want to be Superman so that he could be anywhere in an instant. His answer must have been satisfactory because he was offered the job.
2. If you were a cereal box on a long grocery store aisle, why would I put you in my shopping cart when there are so many other boxes?
George Tomko, a former CIO who's now an IT consultant, says he had to restrain himself from rolling his eyes when he was asked this one. He understood the hiring manager wanted to know what made him unique; he just wished the hiring manager could have been more direct and less cutesy.
3. If you were an IP address, what would it be?
Stapleton doesn't remember how he answered this question—only that he said he would not be the loop back address (the IP address of one's own computer.) He thinks he was asked this question to demonstrate that he understood how IP addresses worked.
4. If you didn't have any financial obligations, what would you be doing with your time?
Brian Nettles, the director of enterprise systems at CB Richard Ellis, uses this question to learn about a prospective employee's personal interests. If the candidate says he wouldn't be working in IT, that's a red flag for Nettles. It tells him the individual doesn't have much passion for his job.
5. How does a computer mouse work?
Stapleton says he had to explain the mechanics of a mouse when he interviewed for an IT management position. He believes the hiring manager wanted to make sure he could explain technical concepts in laymen's terms. He say he answered the question simply: "The movement of the mouse creates electronic signals, which get sent to the computer, which understands which direction to move in."
If you're an IT hiring manager, please share your unconventional interview questions. Are you
Meridith, You are starting to remind me of the person that can quote every stat on every player in the NFL and when you ask where they played ball at, they didn't. Not even in high school. I have personally interviewed over 1000 candidates in the IT world, filled more than 200 searches and have never run into this crap. ( yes, I have been interviewed over 150 times myself ) Is this a slow news day or what. How about REAL company interview questions ( On this CRM install you designed, deployed & implemented, what was your biggest challenge to success & how did you overcome it ? ) These sound like FaceBook or TMZ questions, maybe that's how professional interviews are done these days.......still love ya babe
The correct answer to the question, "If I were an IP address, what would I be?" is just too obvious. "If I were an IP address, I would be Dynamic. Being flexible and open to change in today's environment is crucial.", IMHO
Wow, I cannot disagree more with Mr. Nettles' reasoning behind asking question #4 ("If you didn't have any financial obligations, what would you be doing with your time?"). If the candidate says something other than "I'd be working in IT", it tells him that they don't have much passion for their job? What about the person who says, "I'd spend my time helping disabled vets learn to use their new prosthetic limbs", or "I'd build low-cost battery powered motorcycles" or even, "I'd be fishing!". He says he asks that question to learn about the candidate's personal interests. A well-rounded individual can be very passionate about their work while they are at work and be just as passionate about something else during their off time. The answer that he wants to hear will only come from people who, when asked, "What is one of your weaknesses?" answer with, "I work too hard"... (groan)
It seems that HR interviewers are trying to get some kind of general concept from the applicant by asking totally astonishing questions such as which IP would you be, what would you do if you were a millionnaire, and so on and so forth. In my opinion, all these questions are just crap. I've been asked even more sillier questions myself in hundreds of interviews and then landed the position applied for because of my skills, experience and or background.