Rants
Questions
Soapbox
Best Practices
Apply today for a FREE subscription to CIO Magazine!
Sun, Jun 10, 2007 0:16 EDT
|
Posted by: Michael Kavis in Rants Topic: ApplicationsBlog: Delivering the Goods
Current Rating: |
We have seen the .Com bubble and the real estate bubble burst over the last few years. These two events had a similar scenario. The early adopters made a ton of money, valuations went through the roof to the point that it didn't even make sense, and then everybody in the neighborhood started getting into it. The lesson learned is when valuations start getting insane, it's time to leave. When everyone you work with is talking about it at the water cooler, it's too late.
Having learned those lessons, I see something that is starting to smell like a rat. Private equity firms are buying cash flow positive public companies like there is no tomorrow. They spend the next 2-3 years preparing to sell these companies for huge profits. These investment firms have found out that there is more money to be made in purchasing companies then there is on the stock market.
I also see Google, Yahoo, and Microsoft spending crazy money in a race to buy up all of the no-name Web 2.0 startups. The valuations of these companies are getting crazy. Danger Will Robinson! If this follows the trend of the last two bubbles, then it is time to get out. Sure there is still a ton of money to be made but how many people do you know who bought that second or third condo at the peak of the bubble? I bet they wish they would have seen the signs.
The private equity firms are borrowing huge sums of money to purchase these companies. They have no intention of paying it off. When they sell the company they will make millions or even billions, but the buyer will have huge debts to pay off. What will be the impact to our economy when we have companies that are as over extended as the public is with their credit cards? What is going to happen when Google wakes up to the fact that they have spent billions of dollars on several niche Web 2.0 companies? I am sure some of Google's purchases like YouTube will pan out but some of the 40 acquisitions that they made in the last 8 years have got to fail.
The other thing that scares me is the longevity of web advertising. Search Google for "blogging for money" and it will return well over
Michael:
Thanks for your post, which I found quite interesting. While I am not going to worry for the private equity firms, I feel less sure about the WEB 2.0 phenomenon.
I am on the impression that Google and the likes would either purchase companies with a large audience, or whose products fills a hole in their own offer. Granted, they often pay a price that looks insane for them. However, it leaves the vast majority of WEB 2.0 companies struggling to get an audience, or market traction. I am not even sure that visible companies like SociaText for instance would get a good valuation if sold.
During the .com bubble, any simple company, even the dumbest ones, got insane valuation.
My 2 cents …
I was in a Silicon Valley networking event just a few days after Google bought YouTube. Three out of ten entrepreneurs in the room had already started working on YouTube variants. What was shocking was that they were actually receiving quite a bit of interest from VCs. Since then I heard of at least three companies with some variant of video sharing / online video production that received venture or angel funding. Now, I don’t know the details of these companies so it is possible that they are really good investments. However, on the surface this sure looks like a bubble to me.
Nice post Mike. I get so tired of hearing folks talk about Web 2.0 while ignoring low hanging fruit that can be solved with "Web GetItDoneNow.0"
I totally agreed with you that this is a "bubble". I believe that many cash-ridden companies such as Goggle and Microsoft will go on buying shopping sprees just to make the news.
I feel that it is totally unethical for private equity firms to "flip" those small companies for their selfish financial gains while ignoring the fact that when companies are bought out, many of the workers receive pink slips.
I believe that Goggle eventually will struggle at low-30 as Microsoft. $450+ for their shares are just insane.
Michael,
You are on the money, no pun intended, about the private equity bubble that is about to implode. Unfortunately, the looming shakeout will affect more than the stock market. Virtually all of these deals are highly leveraged with debt. Unless the economy can withstand the decline in the stock market, many of these companies will not be able to generate the cash needed to service this debt. This will send secondary shocks through the banking industry, that would further harm the economy. Of course, the private equity guys who cashed out in time will be lurking to buy up these distressed and bankrupt companies at pennies on the dollar. Not a pretty sight for the rest of us.