Mon, Feb 1, 2010 14:15 EST

Enterprise IT's Top Enemy: Its Own Arrogance

A new video pokes fun at the fact that the man on the street doesn't know what BI means, which is IT's problem in a nutshell.

Topic: Applications

Blog: Enterprise Software Unplugged

Current Rating: 4 Comments: 12

The "man on the street" video starts off harmless enough. Andy Bitterer, the co-chair of the Gartner's BI Summit, is in London trying to hunt down any commoners who know about business intelligence tools, data warehousing and corporate performance management.

Take a look:

Gartner BI Summit: London Interviews

Not surprisingly, few experts could be found. I admit, I chuckled a few times, and Bitterer seems like a nice enough chap.

But then I got to thinking about it some more. And it dawned on me that this video is, ironically, the perfect representation of the self-inflicted image problem that IT departments' and the entire IT industry itself have suffered from for decades: A technological arrogance that lurks behind and manifests itself in arcane techno mumbo-jumbo and smug conceit, that, for lack of a better word, really pisses off end users and has turned them against IT departments.

Do you know what a data warehouse is? How about OLAP or ETL tools? Do you have any idea what a database is? Business intelligence?

A befuddled Bitterer sums up: "People don't seem to know about business intelligence!" Shame on you stupid users!

In their own way, the interviewees actually provided Bitterer and the rest of us with the answer to what users most want from IT today—simplicity and ease of use in their software. One woman mentions Excel as her database tool, and one guy says: "I just use the Internet, really."

That shouldn't surprise anyone, especially when considering the massive uptake in SaaS applications: Those intuitive, easily accessible apps that users are flocking to.

Quite simply, IT today has to play the role of "interpreter" for users and then deliver the software that can help users get their jobs done. Period. Can you use a computer? Yes. Can you intuitively understand basic software? Yes. Do you have an Internet connection? Yes. Then you should be good to go. The "consumerization of IT" proves that the masses do care about and love all things tech.

That the "dim masses" of business users don't know the difference between Unix and Linux is not their concern. That's IT's concern.

Look at cars today. My Honda Pilot is one complicated machine, but you don't see the Honda engineers hanging it over my head that I don't know what an iVTEC engine is or how a Variable Cylinder Management functions. The interface on the Pilot is pretty darn intuitive: key in ignition, foot on break, shift into gear and go. The stereo, the heating system, the dashboard—all extremely uncomplicated.

For IT, it appears that the legacy of the past—in the form of a condescending gate-keeper role—is still alive and well. And that's too bad.

To many IT folks and analysts, there were some yucks to be had from that video. But, in fact, the joke is actually on Bitterer and all of the rest of us who feel a sense of importance over the common blokes who know nothing of OLAP and ETL tools.

Which is why IT is, in far too many companies, still viewed as a cost center not to be taken very seriously.

Follow me on Twitter @twailgum. Follow everything from CIO.com on Twitter @CIOonline.

You do not have flash or javascript support.
Average (1 vote)
4
 
 
Mon, Feb 1, 2010 16:09 EST
Posted by: Bill Wood
Rating: 50

Great post, couldn't agree more! And this is the "beauty" of Apple innovation. It is customer centered and customer focused simplicity.

This is also one of those things that aggravates me on some projects when the consultants either don't know how to consult, or they use techno-babble to hide their lack of business knowledge!

Bill Wood
R3Now Consulting
Results Oriented SAP Solutions
http://www.r3now.com
(704) 905 - 5175
http://www.linkedin.com/in/billwood

 
Tue, Feb 2, 2010 9:33 EST
Anonymous user
Posted by: SMC
Rating:

This article goes to the heart of why we see such a disconnect in corporate environments. Many technologies are still too complex, and the people who run IT often like it this way because it helps them retain power; I work in IT and I know this attitude first-hand.

It's also why 'consumer' technologies (i.e., easy to use) are making their way into the office. IT's focus on security and standards sometimes masks their real intention, which is control.

 
Tue, Feb 2, 2010 12:24 EST
Anonymous user
Posted by: Brian Sanchez
Rating:

We see this disconnect almost universally, from small 5-person outfits up to fortune 500 corporations. As an ERP software developer, having expertise in business consultation and technical knowledge is a must, but it's also a curse. The moment we exhibit IT-competancy, many clients glom onto us with all sorts of semi-related IT requests. Mind you, this includes companies WITH IT departments! I can't tell you how many servers or network routers we've configured.

We are happy to do whatever it takes to get the job done, but many times clients ask us for IT assistance simply because their own IT departments are uncooperative.

Brian Sanchez
Senior Developer, aACE Business Mgmt Suite
Avant Garde Information Solutions, LLC

 
Tue, Feb 2, 2010 13:51 EST
Anonymous user
Posted by: Anonymous
Rating:

Great post, i agree. unfortunately, it's easier said than done.

And regarding "customer-centric Apple", you must be kidding. I don't know a company that would be more arrogant towards a customer. Be it a refusal to fix a Mac that comes from a smoker, an attempt to hide the fact that a battery can explode, or the software that craps all over my harddrive and registry given half a chance.

 
Tue, Feb 2, 2010 17:23 EST
Posted by: Bill Wood
Rating:

If you are referring to my post I did not say that Apple the company was "customer-centric" but its products, innovation, and development efforts are absolutely 100% customer centric.

Jobs is fanatical about customer-centered design and innovation. That is Apple's value proposition, innovation. I'm not sure I would call it customer focused, but rather customer-focused innovation.

Read the article on wrote on this very topic:

Business Strategy and IT Strategy to Reproduce Apple Innovation

Bill Wood
R3Now Consulting
Results Oriented SAP Solutions
http://www.r3now.com
(704) 905 - 5175
http://www.linkedin.com/in/billwood

Post new comment

* Subject:
* Username:
* E-mail:
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Homepage:
* Body:
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <blockquote> <strike> <p> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
More information about formatting options

* Denotes required field.

About this Blog

All that's right and wrong with the business of enterprise software: A cold, hard look at ERP, CRM, BI and Supply Chain applications.

Hot Conversations

How To Manage Global Projects With Remote Resources

Posted by Jim Vaughan in Best Practices | 3 comments

Evolution Was Bad for Neanderthals

Posted by Brian Hopkins in Best Practices | 2 comments

Start a Conversation
Click to post

Got something to say? We want to hear it! Click the Post button to get started. GO»

EXPERT ADVICE
See our roster of experts.

Advice & Opinion from more than 123 of IT's most insightful thinkers.

Effectively Address your Biggest IT Challenges

Take a holistic approach to storage planning to reap the most success possible in today's IT environment. Enterprise Strategy Group explains how to select the right tools to build a virtualized, efficient data center by reducing your storage footprint, streamlining operations, and simplifying storage management.

Sponsored by NetApp  Read More »

 

Improve Service Levels while Cutting Costs

Identification of underperforming processes for databases, operations, systems, storage and capacity management is the first step to service optimization. But where do you start? This paper will help you identify the areas for improvement and explains how IT workload automation can significantly reduce complexity and IT staff inefficiencies.

Sponsored by BMC  Read this White Paper »

 

4 Steps to Maximize Website Search

Learn about the 4 key steps to ensure effective search and Google's many options to transform your organization's site into a more powerful tool.

Sponsored by Google GSA  Read this White Paper »

Mobile Computing Trends 2010

Users are demanding faster access to business applications and want devices that have the latest features that they can be proud to demonstrate in front of clients and partners. Defining a mobile strategy, standardizing laptops, notebook, tablets and smart phones can be a daunting task - especially for smaller organizations where IT is already wearing so many hats. Learn how to cost-effectively meet these demands while ensuring security and staying within budget.  View Now »

 

Advancing Knowledge Sharing with Google: The LSNC Story

In the modern work environment, knowledge sharing has become paramount to organizational success, given the geographic dispersion, mobility, and information overload...  View Now »

 

It's time to stick a fork in the traditional desktop - reinventing client computing with a flexible, service-oriented approach

Though often viewed as a non-strategic commodity by IT, today's desktop is a primary barrier to end-user satisfaction, IT effectiveness, and business flexibility. It's time for enterprise IT to acknowledge the problem and eliminate it.  View Now »

 
Newsletter Sign-Up »

Receive the latest news test, reviews and trends on your favorite technology topics